THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Rutherford, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated July 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Fiorentini Restaurant is a charming gem in Rutherford. Its smaller menu offers a range of excellent options, and service is equally impressive. The warm and inviting interior, combined with great service and good food, make it a great choice. Known for being BYOB, with a liquor store conveniently located across the street.”

Customers` Favorites

“Matisse 167 is a top choice for special occasions, offering a slightly expensive menu that never disappoints. The outdoor garden seating is a beautiful setting for the artful dishes that arrive in perfect succession. The sea bass over risotto, crab, and pineapple is a standout dish, along with the fried artichoke over burrata and the crab and shrimp dish. The chef's talent shines through in every dish, making each visit a delightful experience worth repeating.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mr. Roy's Grill is a hidden gem that lives up to its great reviews. This small but tasty restaurant offers a variety of delicious dishes, including huge and juicy chicken tenders, ribs, rotisserie chicken, burgers, General Tso's, and chopped cheese sandwiches. The friendly and accommodating staff provide a welcoming atmosphere, complete with good music. Vegetarian options are available, including a Veggie Panini, Veggie Wrap, Veggie Burrito, and Veggie Burger. This kid-friendly spot is a must-visit for its mouth-watering chicken tenders, served with a side of hospitality. With its updated menu, there's always something new to try at Mr. Roy's Grill.”

Customers` Favorites

“Be Well Greens is a favorite spot for healthy, freshly made food in a friendly and upbeat atmosphere. The outdoor seating area, surrounded by plants and flowers, is a perfect spot to enjoy their delicious dishes. Popular items include the green goddess salad, black bean wrap, California wrap, Moroccan lentil, and cauliflower chickpea curry. The staff is lovely and welcoming, and their smoothies are a hit. This vegetarian-friendly spot serves flavorful and healthy options, including cashew ricotta and pear, lentil soup, and cauliflower stew, leaving customers feeling great and eager to return.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tenmomi is a ghost kitchen that offers pick-up only service. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including porky buns and unique Filipino-Japanese ramen. The porky buns are soft and filled with tender pork and pickles, while the Ube sesame ramen features a blend of Filipino and Japanese flavors. The fried thighs on top of the ramen might be some of the best fried chicken. The noodles have a great chew and the broth is slightly sweet and earthy.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taqueria Nacho Libre is a top-notch Mexican restaurant in town, offering delicious and fresh food that rivals homemade cooking. The staff is welcoming, with a gentleman waiter who recommends the best dishes. Their Birria tacos are a flavor-packed must-try, even for those familiar with authentic Mexican cuisine. The friendly service and authentic food make it a go-to spot for dine-in or pickup, truly standing out as one of the best Mexican restaurants in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“Greek Town Gyros is a small, clean restaurant serving traditional Greek cuisine. The pit-cooked gyros are made with fresh ingredients and are delicious. Portion sizes are large, and prices are fair. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy. BYOB is allowed, and a liquor store is nearby. Favorites include the chicken and gyro platters, chicken souvlaki, and crispy onion rings and shoestring fries. The rice pudding is also a must-try.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dumpling Dojo offers an amazing dining experience with a variety of options to choose from. The restaurant serves delicious food, including the popular general tao chicken and cajun seasoned pork with butter noodles, which feature very soft noodles with amazing texture and flavorful sauces. The butter chicken dumplings are a must-try, with a side of teriyaki sauce. The service is fast and friendly, making it a great spot to visit with friends or a partner. While not every dish may be a hit, the overall experience is enjoyable and deserves more recognition.”

Customers` Favorites

“Yamada Sushi is a beloved spot with a great atmosphere and top-quality sushi and sashimi. The friendly staff provides excellent service, making you feel like a valued guest. While the mango tango roll is a favorite, all the dishes are very good. The owner, Charlie, ensures the sushi is always fresh and tasty. For a more relaxed dining experience, visit during the week and don't forget to bring your own drink. Just be wary of potentially longer wait times than initially stated for pick up orders.”

Customers` Favorites

“Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen offers a delightful atmosphere with amazing service. The pizza is a highlight, with options like Calzone and veggie pizza with generous toppings. While some found the toppings overwhelming, the delicious crust and sauce make up for it. The staff is friendly, and there's free parking available. Overall, Ferazzoli's is a great spot to enjoy delicious pizza and desserts like ice cream sweet pizzas. If you're in the area, it's definitely worth a try - you won't regret it!”

Customers` Favorites

“Rutherford Pancake House is a lovely location with great food and friendly service. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including a bacon, chicken sandwich with pancakes. While the food is great, there have been some issues with custom requests not being fully met. Despite this, the restaurant has a nice decor and reasonable prices. They are particularly accommodating for families with special dietary needs, making it a great option for a family outing. Overall, Rutherford Pancake House is a highly recommended spot for a delicious meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Domodachi Sushi offers a variety of delicious dishes, from seared salmon appetizers to chicken teriyaki entrees. The regular rolls like salmon avocado and Philly are big and filling. The beautifully crafted sushi platter for takeout was of high quality, making it the best sushi in town. The service is prompt, and the staff are super nice. A must-try for sushi lovers!”

Customers` Favorites

“Matera's Italian Market is a wonderful restaurant that offers delicious food and a lovely selection of Italian products. Customers appreciate their sponsorship in local events, such as the Relay for Life. The sandwiches, especially those prepared by Antonella, are consistently fresh and delicious. The chicken parm is highly recommended, and their rainbow cookies are a must-try. The service is excellent, and the atmosphere is inviting, making it a great spot for a meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sabor Peru offers a delightful dining experience with welcoming staff and excellent service. The food is delicious, with standout dishes including ceviche, maduros, and empanadas. The owner, Diana, shares the makeup of each dish, featuring many enjoyable flavors and wholesome ingredients. The restaurant has a warm, fresh, and stylish atmosphere. It's a great spot for Peruvian cuisine, with some Dominican fusion, and offers tasty desserts like flan and tres leches. It's recommended to call ahead for reservations as seating is limited. Overall, Sabor Peru is a fantastic choice for a memorable meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Steve & Andrea's is a local favorite spot for brunch and lunch. They offer delicious specials, with changing soups every few days. The homemade chips and hash are must-try staples. Customers recommend the Huevos rancheros and crepe pancakes, but suggest ordering a full plate of pancakes for sharing. The coffee may taste burnt, but the food makes up for it. The servers are friendly, attentive, and quick with witty remarks and recommendations. While there may be a wait for a table on busy days, the reasonable prices and comfortable seating make it worth the visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“DB Breakfast is highly recommended for its delicious cinnamon bun and variety of pastries, including one with apple, that are sure to delight. The coffee is also enjoyable and the staff is known for their kindness and excellent service. It is a great spot for a morning meal and has become a regular place for many locals in Rutherford.”

Customers` Favorites

“Ara Coffee is a hidden treasure serving amazing coffee made from freshly roasted beans on site. This cute shop has a sweet and helpful staff, offering alternative milks and gluten-free options like banana bread. With great vibes and affordable prices, it's a must-visit for coffee lovers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sweet Avenue Bake Shop is a beloved bakery known for its delicious vegan cupcakes and cakes. The bakery, which has a modern interior with a retro feel, has been satisfying customers for over eight years. Their truffle cake pops and personalized birthday cakes are particularly popular. The staff, including Danielle and her team, are known for their friendliness and excellent customer service. The bakery offers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions. Located in Rutherford, it is worth the trip for anyone looking for high-quality baked goods.”

Customers` Favorites

“Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery is a hidden gem in Rutherford, offering a unique and delicious experience. The bakery is renowned for its delectable pastries, including the popular citrus olive oil cakes. The coffee is also a highlight, with a variety of flavors to choose from. The shop's interior is beautifully decorated with plants and fresh flowers, creating a tranquil atmosphere. The staff is friendly and patient, making customers feel relaxed and welcomed.”

Customers` Favorites

“Ice Cream Charlie's is a classic "mom and pop" shop that serves up delicious homemade ice cream. The shop has a vast selection of flavors, including unique options like Banana Chunk. The ice cream is rich and flavorful, and the staff is friendly, polite, and helpful. The shop is clean and well-organized, with in-shop seating available. Note that Ice Cream Charlie's only accepts cash, but the unique flavors and excellent service make it a worthwhile stop for ice cream lovers.”

Customers` Favorites

“30 Burgers is a remarkable burger restaurant that offers an unforgettable dining experience for all burger enthusiasts. The mouthwatering selection of patties, toppings, and sauces, along with fresh ingredients and soft buns, creates a perfect harmony of taste and texture. The restaurant offers a great selection for vegetarians and is super kid-friendly with a nice kids' menu.The service is friendly, the atmosphere is inviting, and the prices are affordable, making dining at 30 Burgers a truly exceptional experience. The restaurant offers a variety of options, from classic cheeseburgers to gourmet creations, as well as delicious sides like cheese fries and mozzarella sticks. Don't forget to try their Oreo milkshake, which is absolutely amazing.The cleanliness and attention to detail at 30 Burgers add to the overall memorable experience. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a gourmet burger feast, 30 Burgers will exceed your expectations. In a world filled with burger joints, 30 Burgers stands out with its culinary mastery and commitment to excellence. Prepare to have your taste buds dazzled and your burger expectations forever elevated.”

Customers` Favorites

“Suprema, a quaint restaurant on Rutherford Main Street, offers fantastic service and amazing food. Guests can enjoy a variety of dishes, including calamari, rice balls, and a parmesan chicken sandwich, all of which are delicious. The restaurant features both indoor and outdoor seating, and is known for its fresh, high-quality menu items and friendly staff.”

Customers` Favorites

“Song E Napule offers great pizza with unique dough, delicious pasta cooked to perfection, and flavorful meatball starters. The lemon sponge cake for dessert is a must-try, along with a finishing cappuccino. The restaurant provides attentive and friendly service, with a beautiful atmosphere for dining. While some guests found limited gluten-free options, others enjoyed special pizzas like the smoked burrata, mortadella, and pistachio pesto combination. Overall, a place worth revisiting for an improved dining experience.”

“Varrelmann's Bake Shop is a family-owned bakery serving authentic German treats like apple strudel. They offer a wide selection of freshly baked breads, scones, pies, and cupcakes in various flavors. Their sweet treats are never too sweet, and their staff is friendly. Upon entering, customers are greeted by a wonderful sweet aroma. With a cozy environment, Varrelmann's Bake Shop is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. They have something for everyone, from cheese scones to blueberry scones and chocolate croissants.”

Customers` Favorites

“Steven's Cafe is a welcoming spot in downtown Rutherford, perfect for a casual meal or a coffee break. The contemporary atmosphere and friendly staff create a pleasant experience. The menu offers a variety of options, including the must-try Mediterranean Omelette. While some items are only available until 4 PM, the overall experience of enjoying a Biston Creme donut or a cup of coffee makes it worth a return visit. With convenient parking and a relaxing ambiance, it's a great place to unwind with friends or get some work done.”

Customers` Favorites

“Kabob on the Cliff is a Persian restaurant located in North Jersey that offers a cozy and casual dining experience. The restaurant is known for its Tahdig, a crispy rice dish, which can be topped with a variety of stews, including Gheimeh (beef and split pea stewed in tomato sauce.) The Koobideh, a ground beef kebab, is also a popular choice among customers.The service at the restaurant is excellent, with the owner, who is also the only waitstaff, providing prompt and friendly service. The menu offers a variety of options, including Persian stews, salads, and side dishes, as well as kabobs that are prepared to perfection.The restaurant is fortunate to have many regular customers from the Rutherford area who enjoy the terrific Persian cuisine, airy storefront café, and friendly staff. The restaurant also features a Noruz Haft-seen display during the new year, making it a great place to celebrate.Overall, Kabob on the Cliff is a great spot for Persian food that is worth the drive, with excellent food quality and great service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Roll Thai'd Creamery offers a variety of bubble tea and rolled ice cream options. The staff is described as sweet and remembering regular orders. The restaurant has a fun, positive atmosphere with post-its on the walls. Customers praise the excellent rolled ice cream, delicious tea and boba, and good service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Rutherford Coffee Co. is a Colombian cafe with amazing customer service and delicious offerings like Columbia pandebano, palito de queso con guayaba, and Milo chocolate Frappuccino. The cozy atmosphere is perfect for enjoying coffee, chai with cinnamon, and oatmeal cookies. A must-visit spot for a special coffee experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“BeiJing Hot Pot is a restaurant that offers a delicious and fresh hot pot experience. The food may take some time to be served as it is made fresh, but it is worth the wait. The spicy broth is a great option for those who are looking for flavorful dishes, and it's especially suitable for Chinese Muslim customers. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere, and it can accommodate around 20 people. The prices are reasonable, and they offer a variety of dishes, including BBQ skewers. The restaurant is a great place for families, as they offer kid-friendly options.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cafe Amore, located inside an office building in Rutherford, NJ, offers fresh food quickly and at great prices. The cafe serves a variety of dishes, including the popular club med sandwich, which features eggplant, roasted peppers, provolone, and pesto mayo, as well as fried zucchini and other vegetarian options. The staff is informative and accommodating, catering to dietary restrictions such as vegan and dairy-free requests. With affordable prices and a wide range of options, Cafe Amore is a great place to grab a quick bite or order catering for a group.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sonoma Bistro is a beautiful restaurant with amazing food, from appetizer to main course, and good drinks. The ambiance is beautifully decorated, and the service is fast and friendly. The brunch menu offers delicious dishes such as chicken and waffles and omelettes, and mimosas are perfectly made. The restaurant is a great spot to gather with friends and family for a wonderful dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Azteca is a Mexican restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The menu features a variety of classic dishes, including steak nachos, al pastor tacos, and birria tacos. Customers have praised the generous portions, fresh ingredients, and friendly service. The restaurant also caters to vegetarian diners with a great selection of meatless options. Azteca's homemade Mexican cuisine, with a touch of family secrets, is sure to satisfy any craving for authentic flavors.”

Customers` Favorites

“Ondubu is a popular lunch spot, serving hot and delicious food. The staff is accommodating and labels dishes with names, making it easy to order for groups. Menu highlights include the Bibimbap, Pork Mandu, and Beef Ttukbaegi, which offer rich flavors and satisfying portions. The Beef Bao Bun is also a notable dish.”

Customers` Favorites

“Yan Asian, located on Park Ave in Rutherford, is a highly recommended take-out restaurant known for its delicious and fresh Asian cuisine. The restaurant is family-run, with a husband and wife team who are praised for their friendliness and accommodating nature. Customers appreciate the care put into preparing the meals, especially the highly recommended dumplings, fried wontons, and egg rolls. The pad thai has the right amount of spice, and the menu offers a variety of options to choose from. Yan Asian is considered the best Asian cuisine in Rutherford, making it a popular choice for those seeking a taste of Asia in New Jersey.”

Customers` Favorites

“Boom Boom Chicken offers a mix of experiences. The food is generally average, with moist chicken that could use more sauce, and onion rings that have an unusual mashed texture. The service is mostly polite, though cleaning of tables could be improved. Customers have varying opinions on the speed of the "to-go" orders, but overall the experience is satisfactory.”

Customers` Favorites

“Da Mario Pizzeria is a local, family-friendly spot known for its flavorful food and old-school vibe. Customers love their sausage and peppers, spaghetti, and meatballs, as well as their thin-crust pizza with onions. The staff is friendly, the pricing is affordable, and the service is good. It's the perfect go-to place in the area for a quick, delicious meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Volares offers exceptional food and service, making diners feel like they are in Little Italy. With a wide menu selection, including a delicious black linguine with scallops and shrimp, guests enjoy a relaxed dining experience. The owner's personal touch, like reducing the bill and offering a free dessert, shows care and commitment to customer satisfaction. This restaurant is a must-visit for those who appreciate authentic Italian cuisine.”

Customers` Favorites

“Yellowtail is a restaurant known for its delicious and fresh sushi, with standout dishes including crispy rice and the salmon avocado roll. The service is praised for being lovely, and the quality of the food is exceptional. It's reported to be on par with high-end sushi restaurants like Nobu. A must-try for sushi lovers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mambo Latin Kitchen & Empanadas is a restaurant that offers delicious and generous portions of food, including their empanadas, mofongo, and tres leches. The restaurant has a fun and lively atmosphere with upbeat music and a BYOB policy. The owner, EJ, is known for his accommodating and positive personality, making it a great place for special events. The service is exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to make the experience memorable. The restaurant is small, so it is recommended to make a reservation for groups of more than two people. Overall, Mambo Latin Kitchen & Empanadas is a great choice for those looking for delicious food, a fun environment, and excellent service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dunkin', located near a laundromat, is a convenient spot for a quick and affordable meal. The service is straightforward, and the pastries are relatively inexpensive. While the sandwiches may not always be perfect, they are prepared quickly. The seating is comfortable, and the store at 310 Union Ave, Rutherford NJ, plays the DD Satellite Music Channel, creating a pleasant atmosphere for dining. Overall, Dunkin' offers a no-frills, efficient experience with friendly service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Finch's, the restaurant located within the Renaissance Meadowlands Hotel, offers a peaceful dining experience with attentive service. The steak is described as a perfect medium-well strip that cuts like butter, while the mashed potatoes are tasty and plentiful, topped with homemade potato chips. The broccoli, enhanced with minced garlic, is a standout side dish. Though some guests find the prices in the area to be high, others praise the restaurant's pork chops as succulent and the green beans as great. Overall, Finch's is considered one of the better hotel restaurants, with fantastic service and recommended menu items.”

Customers` Favorites

“Jim Dandy's is a restaurant located in a pleasant area, known for its BBQ and offering various options. The General toast, chicken, and yellow rice are popular choices, along with the buffalo wings, dandy fries, ribs, and burgers. The layout and location are also appealing, providing outdoor seating. However, the service and flavor of some dishes have received mixed reviews.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Risotto House is a cozy and welcoming Italian restaurant that has been delighting local diners for years. The small, well-lit space offers a friendly atmosphere, with attentive and helpful staff who provide excellent service. The menu features a wide variety of traditional Italian dishes, including the restaurant's signature risotto, which has been praised for its outstanding quality and flavor.Customers have enjoyed a range of dishes, from the delicious stuffed shrimp over risotto, featuring asparagus and garlic, to the flavorful penne vodka with chicken and the fresh and tasty seafood salad. The mango salad, with its blend of almonds and jalapeño, has also been a hit. For dessert, the tiramisu has been singled out as excellent.The Risotto House is known for its cozy dining experience, with the option to enjoy their dishes for takeout as well. Pricing is considered reasonable, and the restaurant is conveniently located with street parking available. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty Italian meal or a lighter fare, The Risotto House is a reliable and enjoyable dining destination.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mama Rosa Pizza and Pasta is a gem with mouthwatering pizzas and amazing staff. They offer customized vegetarian options and vegan dough, with huge portions and great service. Known as the best pizza place in town, they impress with top-tier specialty slices and delicious penne vodka with chicken. Not only do they have reasonable pricing, but they also provide excellent hospitality and customer service, ensuring quick delivery and delicious food. Mama Rosa is a five-star experience all around.”

Customers` Favorites

“Red Basil Thai Cuisine offers fast service and delicious Thai food. While some experienced dry noodles and not-so-fresh chicken, others praised the spicy noodles and Thai fried rice. The staff is accommodating and friendly, with one customer even having their dish remade when it was too spicy. Despite a mishap with a moisture packet, the restaurant took immediate action. With a wide variety of options and great lunch specials, this Thai spot stands out in the area for both its food and service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Paisano's is a must-try restaurant with amazing pasta dishes, outstanding bread, and delicious calamari. Customers have raved about the excellent service, with servers like Ashley and Raechel being highlighted for their attentiveness and great recommendations. The Branzino and bread pudding are highly recommended dishes. Overall, this restaurant in NJ has left diners pleasantly surprised and eager to return for another fantastic dining experience.”